AutomateDirectUSAMotion LibraryShop the parts catalog

Explainer

Checking Servo Speed Margin for a Rack and Pinion Axis

Motors, gearboxes and drives sizing Published 7 min read

Short answer

Speed here is kinematics, not tuning: 875 ipm through a 30:1 reducer and a 2-inch pitch-diameter pinion takes about 4,178 motor rpm against a 4,200 rpm ceiling, leaving 22 rpm of margin. Cap the ratio near 24:1, or fit a pinion near 2.5 in pitch diameter, so the motor runs at 80% of rated speed at full feed; the torque budget easily follows.

On this page
  1. Travel speed follows the pitch circle
  2. Worked example: 875 ipm through a 30:1 reducer and a 2-inch pinion
  3. What loaded running takes from the 22 rpm
  4. Torque margin says the ratio can come down
  5. What tuning can and cannot recover
  6. Commissioning checks that settle the question
  7. Questions asked

A 30:1 reducer turning a 2-inch pitch-diameter pinion needs about 4,178 rpm at the motor for 875 ipm of rack travel, and the motors planned for this build are rated 4,200 rpm. That leaves 22 rpm — half a percent — before loaded running takes its share, and no tuning recovers rpm the transmission has already spent. The deciding formula is travel speed = motor rpm × π × pitch diameter ÷ ratio, and it says cap this ratio near 24:1 or fit a pinion near 2.5 inches pitch diameter. Torque is not the constraint on this axis; speed is.

Travel speed follows the pitch circle #

Rack travel per pinion revolution equals the pitch-circle circumference, π × pitch diameter — never the outside diameter measured across the teeth. Pitch-line speed in consistent units is v = π × dp × n, with dp the pitch diameter and n the pinion speed in revolutions per minute; inches and revolutions per minute give inches per minute. Through a reducer of ratio i the motor turns i times faster than the pinion, so:

travel speed = motor rpm × π × dp ÷ i

Two ways to confirm dp instead of assuming it: for an inch-series pinion, dp = tooth count ÷ diametral pitch, since DP = N/d by definition; for a metric rack, dp = module × tooth count. The 2-inch figure in this build is treated here as a pitch diameter, and it has to be, because rounding the circumference to a flat 6 inches moves the ceiling by about 40 ipm at this ratio — more than the entire usable margin.

Worked example: 875 ipm through a 30:1 reducer and a 2-inch pinion #

The case is a 4-by-8 plasma and routing table: about 9 ft of X travel, a 200 lb gantry on two servo motors each rated 900 oz-in and 4,200 rpm maximum, each through a 30:1 reducer turning a 2-inch pinion, with a thin-plasma target of 875 ipm.

Input Value Source
Motor rated maximum speed 4,200 rpm motor rating as stated; confirm against the torque-speed curve
Reducer ratio 30:1 proposed reducer identification
Pinion pitch diameter 2 in pinion drawing, treated as pitch diameter
Target cutting speed 875 ipm process requirement
Gantry weight 200 lb on two motors build estimate
Motor torque figure 900 oz-in motor rating; verify continuous or peak

The rule in words: pinion speed equals travel speed divided by travel per revolution; motor speed equals pinion speed times the ratio; travel per revolution equals π times pitch diameter.

Arithmetic, carried with units:

  • Travel per output revolution = π × 2 in = 6.28 in.
  • Output speed for 875 ipm = 875 in/min ÷ 6.28 in/rev = 139 rpm.
  • Motor speed = 139 rpm × 30 = 4,178 rpm.
  • Margin = 4,200 rpm − 4,178 rpm = 22 rpm, about 0.5% of rated speed.
  • Kinematic ceiling = (4,200 ÷ 30) rpm × 6.28 in = 140 × 6.28 = 880 ipm.

This is a calculated result for these inputs, not a measured one. The axis makes 875 ipm only by holding the motor at 99.5% of rated speed, which in practice it will not once it carries torque. Use the one-in-five margin as the working rule: keep the motor at or below 80% of rated speed at the highest commanded feed. That means motor speed ≤ 0.80 × 4,200 = 3,360 rpm at 875 ipm, so the ratio must be no more than 3,360 ÷ 139 = 24. Check it: at 24:1 the motor turns 139 × 24 = 3,340 rpm, right at 80%. Decision for this case: 30:1 with a 2-inch pinion is rejected for an 875 ipm axis; use 24:1 or less, or keep 30:1 and fit a pinion of 875 ÷ (3,360 ÷ 30) ÷ π = 2.5 in pitch diameter.

What loaded running takes from the 22 rpm #

A brushed DC servo has no fixed percentage below its rated speed under load. Speed at a given torque comes out of the torque-speed curve for the actual supply: bus voltage, back-EMF constant, winding resistance and the drive's current limit set the operating point, and the rated figure is a ceiling, not an entitlement. If the published curve reaches 4,200 rpm only at negligible torque, usable speed while cutting is lower and the 22 rpm are gone before the first part.

The 900 oz-in figure needs the same discipline: whether it is continuous or peak torque decides which region of the curve the axis may live in. Steady cutting must sit inside the continuous rating; acceleration peaks may borrow the transient rating; repeated full-current ramps through every contour make it a duty-cycle question, and rising motor temperature over a shift is the symptom that settles it. On the drive side, read commanded speed, measured speed, following error and current together: a velocity command that keeps rising while measured speed flattens is a speed, voltage or current limit, not a tuning defect.

Confirm the reducer accepts the input speed too. Reducers carry a permitted input rpm and an efficiency figure, both on the manufacturer's datasheet. The input limit matters because the motor will live near it; the efficiency matters because it multiplies the torque that reaches the rack.

Torque margin says the ratio can come down #

Torque multiplies by the same ratio that divides speed. Converting the motor figure: 900 oz-in ÷ 16 = 56.3 lb-in. At the pinion shaft, 56.3 lb-in × 30 = 1,690 lb-in before reducer efficiency; divided by the 1.0 in pitch radius, one motor presses the rack with about 1,690 lbf. Reducer efficiency from its datasheet is the number that trims this.

Compare that with what the axis asks for. Accelerating a 200 lb gantry at an illustrative 0.25 g ramp (96.6 in/s², using g = 386 in/s²) takes (200 ÷ 386) × 96.6 = 50 lbf, and reaching 875 ipm — 14.6 in/s — at that ramp needs 14.6² ÷ (2 × 96.6) = 1.1 in of travel on a 9 ft axis. Rolling resistance, bearing preload, cable drag and cutting forces add to the 50 lbf, but not by a factor of thirty. So the ratio is free to drop: at 20:1 each motor still delivers 56.3 × 20 = 1,125 lbf of theoretical rack force while the motor turns only 875 × 20 ÷ 6.28 = 2,785 rpm at full feed. Speed is the binding constraint on this axis, and the selection method behind that conclusion is laid out in rack-and-pinion servo choice depending on torque at speed.

Two motors share this force; they do not double the speed. Sharing is only as good as the alignment, coupling stiffness and coordination of the two drives, so check the gantry for position mismatch across the travel rather than assuming balance.

What tuning can and cannot recover #

Tuning shapes how the closed loop responds inside the electrical and mechanical envelope. It cannot raise the bus voltage, extend the torque-speed curve, or change π, so an axis that saturates short of commanded speed stays saturated. Fix saturation in the transmission or the motor, then tune.

Keep the two failure pictures separate. Speed saturation: commanded velocity rises, measured velocity plateaus, current sits at a limit; the fix is ratio, pinion or motor. Following error that grows during ramps while current stays below limit points instead at torque starvation, restrictive profiles, binding or loop gains — and gains pushed past what the mechanics support show up as hunting, the mode behind why a servo motor oscillates between two positions. If the drive class itself is still open, fix a regulation number before comparing motors; the reasoning in choosing servo or stepper for a 1% speed regulation pinch wheel is the same reasoning this axis needs.

Commissioning checks that settle the question #

  1. Confirm dp from the pinion drawing using tooth count with module or diametral pitch, and the ratio from the reducer's identification; do not commission an assumed number.
  2. Verify travel scaling before raising speed: command a counted number of output revolutions and measure rack travel. Ten revolutions should move 10 × 6.28 = 62.8 in at a 2-inch pitch diameter; a mismatch says dp or the ratio is not what the paper claims.
  3. Check the reducer's permitted input speed against the rpm the axis will actually run, and its efficiency against the torque budget.
  4. On older motors, sort out the feedback before scaling travel; identifying geared resolver and encoder feedback on old servos covers the tells.
  5. Ramp feed in steps while watching following error, current and motor temperature; check both sides of the gantry for skew across the full travel, and check contour reversals for backlash lost motion.
  6. Verify travel limits and stopping distance with the guarding in place before approaching full feed: a 200 lb gantry at 875 ipm is stored energy, and its stopping behavior belongs in the machine's risk assessment.

The decision for this build: 30:1 with a 2-inch pinion does not ship on an 875 ipm axis. Cap the ratio at 24:1, or keep 30:1 with a 2.5-inch pitch-diameter pinion, then re-run the torque and heat check at the new operating point before any tuning work begins.

Questions asked

What gear ratio keeps 875 ipm with real speed margin?

Cap the ratio at about 24:1 with a 2-inch pitch-diameter pinion and a 4,200 rpm motor: that holds the motor at 80% of rated speed at full feed. At 20:1 the motor turns about 2,785 rpm for 875 ipm and the kinematic ceiling rises to about 1,319 ipm, so the feed target stops depending on the last half-percent of the motor range.

Will a loaded servo still reach its 4,200 rpm rating?

Not automatically. A DC servo's speed under load falls out of the torque-speed curve: bus voltage minus back-EMF and the winding-resistance drop sets speed at any torque. Treat the rated speed as a ceiling and size so full feed needs well under it. In this build the 30:1 ratio leaves 22 rpm, which loaded running will consume.

Is the 2-inch pinion size its pitch diameter?

Only the drawing can say. Rack travel follows the pitch-circle circumference, pi times pitch diameter, not the outside diameter measured over the teeth. If 2 inches is an outside measurement, the pitch diameter is smaller and travel per revolution drops below 6.28 inches. Compute pitch diameter from tooth count and module (dp = module x teeth) or diametral pitch (dp = teeth / DP).

Do two motors on the gantry double the available speed?

No. Speed is set once, by motor rpm, ratio and pinion pitch diameter; a second motor adds force and keeps the gantry square, it does not add rpm. Load sharing between the two also depends on alignment, coupling stiffness and coordinated control, so verify position match across the travel rather than assuming equal sharing.

Can drive tuning fix an axis that will not reach commanded speed?

No. Tuning shapes response inside the electrical and mechanical envelope; it cannot extend the torque-speed curve or raise the voltage ceiling. If commanded velocity keeps rising while measured speed flattens, the axis is against a speed, voltage or current limit. Change the ratio, the pinion or the motor, not the gains.

Keep reading

  • Selection guide

    Choosing an Actuator to Compress a Small Spring Precisely

    A 2 lbf (8.90 N) spring over 0.5–0.75 in of travel at 0.025 in steps is a screw problem, not a motor problem: a manual fine-lead screw with a locknut holds the setting with no power. Add a stepper only for remote adjustment, an integrated actuator for automated sequences, or a pneumatic cylinder with an adjustable stop when only endpoint positions matter.

    Motors, gearboxes and drives sizing

  • Selection guide

    Choosing Servo or Stepper for a 1% Speed Regulation Pinch Wheel

    Pick the servo: behind a 45:1 planetary reducer, a velocity-mode servo meets a 1% wheel-speed tolerance with margin, because 200-300 lb-in at 80 rpm needs only 4.9-7.4 lb-in at the motor and the loop corrects load-induced error. A stepper qualifies only when its torque-speed curve clears the load with margin at the required motor speed and a measured ripple test holds the wheel inside 0.8 rpm.

    Servo and stepper motion

  • How-to

    Following a Master Axis With a Stepper Traverse

    Gear the traverse stepper to measured spool rotation, not to a fixed speed ratio: commanded traverse speed is v_t = p × n_s, so pitch stays constant as the spool fills. The follower ratio comes from pitch, screw lead and drive resolution — 25 step pulses per 64 master counts in the worked example — and master acceleration must be limited so the amplified slave ramp cannot stall the open-loop stepper.

    Servo and stepper motion