AutomateDirectUSAMotion LibraryShop the parts catalog

Troubleshooting

Brushed DC Servo Tach Dropout Diagnosis: Why It Jumps

Servo and stepper motion Published 8 min read

Short answer

Jump at one shaft angle plus a speed-synchronous lope after tach work is a dropout in the tach's voltage, not an encoder or alignment fault. Prove it by spinning the feedback shaft and looking for a once-per-revolution notch in tach voltage; a cracked armature conductor needs a replacement armature or feedback unit, not another coat of insulating varnish.

On this page
  1. The measurement that decides the case
  2. Separate the feedback fault from the machine's mechanics
  3. Why encoder alignment is not the cause
  4. What actually matters when a tach armature moves between units
  5. Why another coat of insulating varnish will not fix it
  6. A bench procedure that isolates motor, tach and mechanics
  7. Repair paths and the decision
  8. Questions asked

A brushed DC servo that jumps at the same shaft angle on every jog, then lopes and overshoots after tach armature work, has one decisive fault: the tachometer's output voltage drops out at that angle. A dead commutator segment, a cracked conductor, or an insulating film on the brush track each collapse the tach voltage once per revolution, and the velocity loop reads that as a stall and fires a torque kick. Turn the shaft by hand with the power off: a tach dropout feels smooth, a bad bearing feels rough. That one check splits feedback from mechanics, and every step below follows from it.

The measurement that decides the case #

A brushed DC tachometer is a small generator whose output voltage is proportional to shaft speed, and the velocity loop believes it unconditionally. Put an oscilloscope across the tach armature leads while the shaft turns at a steady speed. A healthy brushed tach shows flat DC with modest ripple: the manufacturer's datasheet for the Servo-Tek CS-7514F-51C tachometer, one documented family, specifies 1.5% peak-to-peak ripple measured through a 72 kHz filter. A dropout instead shows a notch or collapse repeating once per revolution, at the shaft angle where a segment is open, a conductor is cracked, or an insulating film lifts the brush off the land. Velocity-feedback ripple also bounds the speed regulation an axis can hold, the deciding constraint in choosing a servo or stepper for a 1% speed regulation axis.

The loop's reaction is arithmetic. Calculated example, with the tach constant as a stated input rather than a measurement: suppose the nameplate on your tach reads 7.0 V per 1000 rpm, and take the real figure from the nameplate or datasheet of the exact unit. Jogging at 500 rpm, the output should hold 7.0 V × (500 rpm ÷ 1000 rpm) = 3.5 V. Ripple at 1.5% peak-to-peak at that level is 3.5 V × 0.015 = 0.0525 V, about 52 mV.

A notch that drags the signal down 0.5 V for part of a revolution reads to the loop as a speed error of 0.5 V × (1000 rpm ÷ 7.0 V) = 71 rpm, near ten times the ripple that documented tach specifies, so the loop fires a torque kick at that angle on every turn. That kick is the jump, and it lands at the same spot because the fault is fixed to the armature. The control will usually not alarm on any of this: the optical encoder in the combined feedback unit still counts, and encoder loss is what these controls detect, so a tach fault reports itself as motion quality.

Separate the feedback fault from the machine's mechanics #

Not every alarm on a machine like this is the servo. On the machine that prompted this diagnosis, the control's alarm list called alarm 134 a servo error on the X axis, and it tripped when the rapid button was pressed quickly with the motor installed. Pressing rapid steps the commanded velocity; a velocity loop fed by a dropping tach falls behind the step, the position deviation grows, and the control trips its deviation alarm. Alarm 35 appeared at zero return while the Z-axis screw was binding, and its wording belongs to that machine's manual. A binding screw raises torque demand, and the current with it, enough to trip limits no matter how healthy the motor is.

Separate the two physically. With the motor disengaged, push the axis through its full stroke and compare the effort: a drag spot is a mechanical fault, and no feedback repair removes it. On the motor, the signature of the sick velocity loop is specific: ripple that repeats at shaft speed, plus overshoot when you release the jog button and a brief reverse when the motor runs uncoupled from the machine. That is an under-damped loop fed a low, noisy or dropping tach signal. Reversed tach leads are a different fault, giving positive feedback and a runaway rather than a short reverse after a stop, but verify lead polarity after any reassembly anyway.

Why encoder alignment is not the cause #

In a brushed DC motor the brushes and commutator switch the current mechanically, so the encoder's angular position relative to the armature has no effect on torque. Encoder clocking matters only for where the index pulse sits relative to the home switch: get it wrong and zero-return position and repeatability drift, not smoothness. A rotation-synchronous lope after tach work is not an encoder problem, and re-clocking the encoder will not touch it. If you are still sorting out which feedback device an old servo carries, the procedure for identifying geared resolver and encoder feedback on old servos covers combined units of this vintage.

What actually matters when a tach armature moves between units #

The tach armature slips onto the feedback shaft through a hollow bore, a cap screw holds it, and its angular position on that shaft is electrically irrelevant because the brushes are fixed to the housing. What does matter:

  • Voltage constant. The armature sets the tach's scale in volts per 1000 rpm, so a donor with a different constant changes loop gain and damping. Calculated example: an original at 7.0 V per 1000 rpm replaced by a donor at 5.5 V per 1000 rpm scales the velocity loop gain by 5.5 ÷ 7.0 = 0.79, a 21% cut, which shows up as overshoot and that brief reverse after a stop. Read both constants off the nameplates or datasheets and match them.
  • Axial seating and run-out. The armature's depth in the field and its concentricity set the once-per-revolution ripple; one sitting slightly off produces exactly the lope you are chasing.
  • Brush bed-in. New brushes conformed to the old track meet a different wear pattern on a swapped armature and make intermittent contact until they bed in again.
  • Residue. Old brush dust packed between the commutator lands bridges segments and distorts the signal.

These units are not matched pairs that must live and die together: a same-type armature runs correctly when the constants are equal, the lands are clean and the seating is right.

Why another coat of insulating varnish will not fix it #

Any insulating film on the brush track, whether the urethane clear coat tried first or the insulating varnish tried second, adds a contact resistance that varies with film thickness, brush pressure and wear-through. On a tach armature that is voltage noise and dropouts. On the motor armature of a cup-style DC servo, where brushes ride directly on copper inlaid in a fiberglass substrate, a film means arcing and intermittent torque: erratic jumping in rapid and no position hold, which is what appeared after the first recoat.

A coating's job is to bond the substrate and insulate between lands. It cannot restore a fractured conductor; a crack that opens the copper stays open under the best varnish in the shop. Switching coatings reduced the symptoms without removing them because all three culprits survive a recoat: stripping residue left in the cracks, varnish still overlapping the brush path, or cracks still open. Insulating coating belongs on the substrate between the lands and never on the brush path. Stop recoating, because each strip-and-coat cycle leaves more residue on the track.

A bench procedure that isolates motor, tach and mechanics #

Lock out the machine to its documented energy-control procedure, OSHA 1910.147 where US practice applies, and confirm zero volts at the drive's power terminals before you uncouple or open anything.

  1. Uncouple the feedback unit from the motor at its flexible coupling, and inspect the coupling while it is apart: a cracked or set element adds run-out of its own, so if the old one is damaged, fit a flexible shaft coupling before reassembly.
  2. Turn the motor shaft by hand with no power applied. Roughness or a repeating detent is bearings or mechanics; that motor goes to a shop, not back on the machine.
  3. Spin the feedback-unit shaft at a steady speed, a hand drill is enough, and watch the tach output on a scope. Flat DC with a few tens of millivolts of ripple is healthy; a notch repeating once per revolution condemns the tach armature or its brush track.
  4. Measure segment-to-segment resistance around the tach commutator with an ohmmeter. Uniform low readings pass; one high or open reading is a dead segment, and no amount of cleaning fixes it.
  5. Verify the tach's voltage constant: spin at a measured speed, divide the output by that speed, and compare with the nameplate and with any donor. For the motor, a no-load run at a known low DC armature voltage with shaft speed measured gives the motor's voltage constant for the same comparison.
  6. Check the machine's mechanics with the motor disengaged, full stroke, feeling for the drag that tripped the zero-return alarm.

Repair paths and the decision #

Approach What it fixes Limitation Use it when
Clean the brush track, re-seat the armature Residue, loose seat, run-out ripple Does not repair an open conductor Segment-to-segment readings are uniform and the scope shows no notch
Strip the coating back to bare copper on the track Contact-resistance noise from film overlap Cracks stay; thin inlaid copper damages easily Coating overlaps the brush path but the segments still measure continuous
Fit an armature from a donor unit A dead segment or cracked land on one armature Unknown wear history; constant must match; brushes must re-bed The donor's voltage constant matches and its armature scopes clean
Replace the complete feedback unit as a set Armature, field, brushes and encoder together Must be the same part number; used units carry wear The armature or field shows cracks or inconsistent output
Professional rebuild of the armature Cracked substrate and conductor Lead time No clean donor exists

The decision, case by case. The scope shows a clean tach and the motor hand-turns smooth, but the axis still binds: fix the machine mechanics, because the servo is not the fault. The scope shows the once-per-revolution notch: the tach armature is condemned, so fit a donor armature with a matching voltage constant or replace the feedback unit as a set. The ohmmeter or disassembly shows cracked substrate or cracked inlaid copper on either armature: that armature gets replaced or professionally rebuilt, and recoating is finished. The motor jumps erratically in rapid and will not hold position after a recoat: strip the coating off the brush path, and if the copper beneath is cracked, the armature is scrap.

Questions asked

Can I check the tach without an oscilloscope?

Yes, to a point. Spin the feedback shaft at a steady speed and read the tach on a DC voltmeter: a healthy tach holds a steady number, and a dropout shows as a needle or display that dips once per revolution. A meter averages the notch, so it tells you a dropout exists but not its width or depth. The scope is the confirming instrument before you spend money on an armature.

Should the encoder be realigned after the motor is rebuilt?

Only for the home position. In a brushed DC motor the commutator switches the current, so encoder clocking has no effect on torque or smoothness. After a rebuild, verify that zero return lands on the same physical position and repeats; if it does, leave the encoder alone. Chasing smoothness by re-clocking the encoder wastes the afternoon.

Can I compensate a donor tach armature's lower voltage constant by raising the drive's gain?

Yes, if the drive exposes velocity-loop gain and you are willing to re-tune. A donor at 5.5 V per 1000 rpm against an original at 7.0 V per 1000 rpm cuts loop gain to 5.5 divided by 7.0, about 0.79 of design, so the gain setting must rise by 7.0 divided by 5.5, about 1.27 or 27%, to restore damping. Match the constants when you can; compensate only when you cannot, and re-check overshoot afterward.

Is it safe to spin the feedback unit with the tach leads connected to the drive?

No. Disconnect the tach from the drive before any bench spin. A spun tach is a live generator, and a powered drive will act on the signal; if the leads were crossed during reassembly, closing the loop on reversed polarity gives positive feedback and a runaway. Measure polarity with a meter first, then reconnect.

Do the motor and feedback unit have to stay together as a matched set?

No. The motor and the feedback unit are mechanically coupled but electrically independent: the commutator controls torque, the encoder reports position, the tach reports speed. A feedback unit of the same part number runs on any motor of that frame. The matching that matters is inside the tach itself, meaning equal voltage constants and clean seating, not between motor and tach.

Keep reading

  • How-to

    How to Identify Geared Resolver and Encoder Feedback on Old Servos

    Treat the resolver plus its geared 1:4 and 1:80 channels as one integrated coarse-and-fine, multi-turn position package: the resolver reads absolute angle within one shaft revolution, and the geared channels count revolutions above it. Identify each channel by resistance checks, ratio counting and waveform capture before choosing a replacement drive, because the resolver model number alone establishes neither commutation nor multi-turn position recovery.

    Sensors, encoders and machine vision on the machine

  • Troubleshooting

    How to Tell if a Servo Motor Is Actually Faulty

    A servo motor is only confirmed faulty when it still fails with a known-good drive, verified feedback, and the load uncoupled. Read the commanded motion, the measured motion, and the motor current during the same event: high current with no movement points to the load or the feedback, and no command with no movement points upstream of the motor.

    Servo and stepper motion

  • Selection guide

    Choosing Servo or Stepper for a 1% Speed Regulation Pinch Wheel

    Pick the servo: behind a 45:1 planetary reducer, a velocity-mode servo meets a 1% wheel-speed tolerance with margin, because 200-300 lb-in at 80 rpm needs only 4.9-7.4 lb-in at the motor and the loop corrects load-induced error. A stepper qualifies only when its torque-speed curve clears the load with margin at the required motor speed and a measured ripple test holds the wheel inside 0.8 rpm.

    Servo and stepper motion